Mastering CV Assessment: A Comprehensive Guide for Employers

Table of Contents

In the rapidly-evolving job market, mastering the art of CV assessment has become crucial for employers keen on attracting the best talent. This process is much more than a mere resume review; it’s about leveraging tools like applicant tracking systems, understanding the depth of resume skills, and deciphering the nuances within a LinkedIn profile to ensure you’re engaging with candidates who not only fit the job description but also align with your company culture.

With the right approach, employers can significantly enhance their recruitment processes, reducing the time and resources spent on finding the perfect match for their team.

This comprehensive guide will walk you through the essential steps of an effective CV assessment, starting with establishing clear criteria for evaluation, conducting an initial resume screening with a resume checker or an applicant tracking system, and delving deeper into the candidate’s achievements and skills.

We will also explore how to assess a cover letter for customization and effort, why a resume score matters, and how skill assessment plays a critical role in the decision-making process. Finally, we’ll prepare you for the next stages of the recruitment process, ensuring you have all the tools at your disposal to make informed decisions.

Whether you’re new to hiring or looking to refine your approach, this guide will equip you with the knowledge to efficiently identify top talent.

1. Establish Clear Criteria for Evaluation

Define Necessary Skills

To ensure you attract candidates who are the best fit for the role, start by reviewing the job description and engaging with key stakeholders to understand the essential skills required. It’s crucial to identify both hard skills, such as technical knowledge specific to the industry, and soft skills, which include personal habits and traits that influence workplace dynamics.

For instance, an architect would need specific technical skills like using drafting software and a license from the National Council of Architectural Registration Boards.

Distinguish Between Trainable and Additional Skills

While certain skills are mandatory and must be possessed from the outset, others can be developed on the job. It is important to differentiate between these two categories to prioritize essential skills and identify which additional skills could enhance a candidate’s profile.

For example, while technical skills might be crucial for immediate productivity, soft skills like adaptability and teamwork play a significant role in long-term success within the company.

Importance of Creating a Rating Standard

To objectively assess resumes, establish a clear rating standard that you will consistently use throughout the review process. Utilize a predetermined screening instrument to evaluate candidates against these standards. This method helps in maintaining consistency and fairness in the evaluation process.

For instance, you might use a numerical scoring system where specific degrees or experiences are assigned higher points based on their relevance to the position. This structured approach not only streamlines the assessment process but also ensures that the most suitable candidates are identified effectively.

2. Conduct an Initial Resume Screening

Utilize Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS)

Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) are crucial for the initial resume screening process. These systems scan resumes for specific keywords related to the job, such as “SEO” for a marketing manager position, ensuring only the most relevant resumes reach recruiters.

An ATS not only reads and analyzes resumes but also ranks them based on how well they match the job profile, saving employers time by filtering out unqualified applicants. To pass through an ATS, it’s essential to customize your resume with the right keywords and phrases that match the job listing.

Creating a list of Applicant Tracking System (ATS) software with the instruction for URLs to open in new tabs can’t directly incorporate live links here, but I can guide you on how to format URLs in HTML so they open in new tabs. Below is a list of popular ATS software as of my last update, along with a template for how you would format the URLs in HTML.

Some Popular ATS Softwares:

  1. Greenhouse
  2. Lever
  3. Workday
  4. SmartRecruiters
  5. iCIMS
  6. BambooHR
  7. JazzHR
  8. Zoho Recruit

Look for Mandatory Skills and Experience

During the initial screening, focus on identifying candidates who possess the mandatory skills and experience for the role.

This involves looking for specific qualifications and technical abilities required for the position, such as proficiency in certain software or coding languages for a graphic designer role.

Identify Deal-Breakers Early

Early identification of deal-breakers is crucial to streamline the resume screening process. Common deal-breakers include spelling and grammar errors, unexplained gaps in employment, irrelevant information, and inconsistencies between the resume and other materials.

Recognizing these red flags early on helps in narrowing down the pool of candidates to those who are most qualified and attentive to detail.

Employment History and Consistency Check

A thorough check of the candidate’s employment history and consistency is vital. Look for a progressive story in the resume that logically moves from one position to another, indicating stability and growth. Inconsistencies or gaps in the employment history should be noted, as they may raise questions about the candidate’s reliability and work ethic.

Ensuring that the resume provides a clear and accurate representation of the candidate’s work history is key to identifying potential red flags early in the recruitment process.

3. Delve Deeper into the Candidate’s Achievements and Skills

Assess Transferable and Soft Skills

When you’re looking at a CV, it’s essential to identify not just the technical skills but also the transferable and soft skills that the candidate brings to the table. Transferable skills, such as communication, critical thinking, self-management, and interpersonal skills, are valuable in many different careers and make a candidate more attractive.

For example, a candidate might not have direct experience in a call centre, but their excellent problem-solving skills and ability to work well in a team could make them a perfect fit. Always highlight these skills in the resume and during job interviews to get a comprehensive view of what the candidate can offer.

Evaluate Specific Achievements and Contributions

It’s also crucial to delve into the candidate’s specific achievements and contributions. Look for concrete examples of accomplishments in their previous roles, such as increased customer satisfaction, streamlined production processes, or successful marketing campaigns.

These achievements demonstrate the candidate’s ability to make a measurable impact and add value to your organisation. Additionally, achievements like media attention for research work or being featured in university recruiting material can provide a competitive edge, as long as they are not the focal point of the CV. Remember, the quality of the content in the CV should take precedence over presentation.

Focus on the Quality of Content Over Presentation

While evaluating a CV, the quality of content is more critical than its presentation. You should allot sufficient time to screen all resumes, comparing the credentials of applicants and focusing on their achievements and skills rather than the format or writing style.

Use a predetermined screening instrument to evaluate candidates against objective criteria and make notes on each candidate. This approach helps in maintaining consistency and fairness in the evaluation process.

Additionally, review the achievements and results highlighted in the candidate’s work history, education, and extracurricular activities to gauge their impact, value, and potential. This detailed assessment ensures you get a fuller picture of the candidate’s capabilities beyond just their job-specific skills.

4. Assess the Cover Letter for Customization and Effort

Indicators of Personalization and Research

When evaluating a cover letter, look for evidence that the candidate has conducted thorough research on your company and the specific role they’re applying for. A personalized cover letter goes beyond merely changing the company name or job title; it demonstrates a deep understanding of your company’s values, culture, and needs.

Candidates should mention how their skills align with the company’s objectives and should reference the company’s recent achievements, culture, or any pain points they might help address.

Personalization shows the candidate’s genuine interest and effort, setting them apart from those who submit generic applications. This not only indicates that they have taken the time to understand what makes your company unique but also that they envision themselves as part of your team, contributing to its success.

Checking for Clarity and Communication Skills

A well-crafted cover letter should also showcase the candidate’s ability to communicate effectively. It should be concise, free from grammatical errors, and formatted for easy reading. Short paragraphs and clear, direct sentences help ensure that the hiring manager can quickly identify the most relevant and compelling information.

The cover letter is an opportunity for candidates to discuss their achievements and skills in a way that adds depth to the information presented in their CV.

They should provide specific examples that highlight their qualifications and how these have positively impacted their previous roles. Additionally, using dynamic vocabulary can add character to the cover letter without overcomplicating it, striking a balance that maintains professionalism while allowing the candidate’s personality to shine through.

By focusing on these aspects, you can gauge a candidate’s potential fit for the role not just in terms of skills and experience, but also in their ability to integrate into your company’s culture and communicate effectively.

5. Prepare for the Next Stages of the Recruitment Process

Formulate Questions for the Interview

When preparing for the next stages of the recruitment process, crafting effective interview questions is crucial. Start by assessing the company’s needs and the job opening to tailor your questions accordingly. Identify the ideal candidate by considering the qualities that may help them meet or exceed the position’s expectations.

Customise your questions to reflect the work environment and company culture, using open-ended questions to encourage candidates to engage in detailed discussions about their qualifications and experiences. Prepare follow-up questions to delve deeper into a candidate’s background, interests, and career goals, ensuring your questions use positive language to value their time and qualifications.

This approach helps you assess whether candidates share the company’s values and possess the soft skills key for the role.

Organize Resumes into ‘Yes’, ‘No’, and ‘Maybe’ Piles

Once all resumes are received, distribute them to the resume review team well in advance of your first meeting.

Have each team member review the resumes individually, categorising them into ‘yes’, ‘no’, or ‘maybe’ piles based on the assessment criteria. In your first resume review meeting, compare the resumes in the ‘yes’ pile to identify any discrepancies and decide which resumes everyone agrees are not right for the position. Work through the pros and cons of each resume in the ‘yes’ or ‘maybe’ piles to narrow down your list of potential candidates.

Transition from Screening to Interviewing

After organising resumes, the transition from screening to interviewing begins with a phone interview, typically the first step with most large companies. The hiring manager, having likely seen your resume, will confirm your skills and clarify any ‘red flags’.

It’s essential to be prepared to discuss your experience in detail, showcasing your ability to perform the job. If successful, you’ll often be invited for an in-person interview. At this stage, companies expect that you have done your research and can articulate why you’re the best person for the job.

To sum up

Through this guide, employers have been equipped with the essential strategies and steps necessary for mastering CV assessment. From establishing clear evaluation criteria, utilizing applicant tracking systems for initial screenings, to delving deeper into candidates’ achievements and skills, and finally assessing the effort in customization and communication skills through cover letters.

This thorough procedure ensures that employers not only attract but also identify the best talents that align with both the job requirements and company culture, thereby enhancing the overall recruitment process.

Moving forward, it is imperative that employers integrate these insights into their hiring strategies to ensure a more efficient and effective screening process. By doing so, they prepare themselves for the next stages of recruitment with a refined pool of qualified candidates.

The significance of this comprehensive approach to CV assessment cannot be understated, as it not only streamlines the hiring process but also significantly contributes to the long-term success of the organization through the acquisition of truly compatible and proficient talents.


1. What constitutes a satisfactory CV score?
A satisfactory CV score is considered to be 70. Achieving this score, as per the guidance from CareerSet, suggests a good standard of CV preparation. Should you reach this score and require further customised advice for specific job applications, it is advisable to consult with a Careers Service.

2. How should I evaluate a CV?
When evaluating a CV, pay close attention to its organisation and look out for any careless errors such as typos or spelling mistakes. Additionally, the presence of clichés, overused buzzwords, or information that does not relate directly to the job can also reflect poorly on the candidate’s professionalism.

3. What are the top three qualities employers seek in a CV?
Employers typically look for the following three qualities in a CV: the ability to learn new skills and adapt to changes, the capability to handle pressure while maintaining effective communication, and being reliable, trustworthy, and capable of teamwork, yet able to operate independently when needed.

4. What is a critical skill that employers evaluate in a resume?
Employers highly value critical thinking and problem-solving skills. Other important skills include teamwork and collaboration, professionalism with a strong work ethic, and proficient oral and written communication skills.

Share 🔗
Contact us
Don’t stop here
More insights

Top Strategies for Effective Staff Development

In the rapidly evolving corporate landscape, staff development stands as a cornerstone for fostering a culture of continuous improvement and innovation. This systemic process not

Scroll to Top